If you're renting a moving truck anyway, towing your car behind it looks like the cheap option. Sometimes it is. But the trailer or dolly rental is only part of the cost, and towing changes the whole drive. Here's what's involved, from U-Haul's and Penske's own rules, and when shipping the car makes more sense.
The short answer
Towing can make sense for a short move, a light front-wheel-drive car, and a driver comfortable with a trailer. For a long move, a heavy, all-wheel-drive or valuable car, or a move where you'd rather fly, shipping usually wins once you count the extra days, fuel and hotels. See your shipping price first, then compare it with a towing quote.
Your two ways to tow
| Tow dolly | Car trailer (auto transport) | |
|---|---|---|
| How it carries the car | Front wheels up, rear wheels on the road | All four wheels on the trailer |
| Max weight | U-Haul: 4,080 lbs · Penske: 4,300 lbs | U-Haul: 5,290 lbs · Penske: 4,055 lbs (16 ft truck) to 5,000 lbs (22–26 ft) |
| Drive type | Best for front-wheel drive; rear-wheel-drive cars need the drive shaft disconnected | Works for front, rear, four- and all-wheel drive |
| Miles on your car | The rear tires roll the whole way | None |
- U-Haul's tow vehicle must weigh at least 750 lbs more than the car on a dolly, and for the auto transport trailer the tow vehicle's curb weight must exceed the loaded trailer's. The trailer itself weighs 2,210 lbs empty.
- Penske's tow dolly and car carrier can only be towed behind a Penske truck, so you rent them together.
- U-Haul's maximum towing speed is 55 mph with a dolly or a car trailer.
What towing costs beyond the rental
- The rental: U-Haul and Penske quote the dolly or trailer for your trip and dates, so get a quote for your exact move.
- Fuel: towing a trailer lowers fuel economy (fueleconomy.gov), and a moving truck already uses a lot of it.
- Time: at 55 mph instead of highway speed, a long move takes longer. Every extra day can mean another hotel night and more meals; for reference, the federal standard travel allowance for 2026 is $110 a night for lodging and $68 a day for meals.
- Risk and effort: backing up with a trailer, tight gas stations, crosswinds and steep grades. If the car or the truck is damaged, that's on you and your insurance.
When shipping makes more sense
- A long move, where days on the road add up.
- An all-wheel-drive, rear-wheel-drive, lowered, heavy or valuable car.
- You'd rather fly, or one person is driving the truck alone.
- The car is too heavy for the dolly or trailer your truck can pull.
- You want the car to arrive after you've unloaded, without a second trip.
With Skrt you see the real price for your route online, licensed carriers request your shipment, and you choose one. There's no deposit, and the flat $99 pick up fee is charged only after the car is picked up.
Is it cheaper to tow a car or ship it?
For a short move, towing is often cheaper. For a long move, the rental plus extra fuel, hotel nights and days off work can come close to or pass the cost of shipping. Compare a towing quote with your shipping price for the same dates.
Can I tow an all-wheel-drive car on a tow dolly?
Usually not without disconnecting the drive shaft. Use a car trailer (auto transport) instead, which carries all four wheels, or ship the car.
How fast can I drive when towing with U-Haul?
U-Haul's maximum speed is 55 mph with its tow dolly and auto transport trailer.
Can I rent a Penske car carrier without a Penske truck?
No. Penske's tow dolly and car carrier are made to be towed behind a Penske truck only.
- U-Haul: Tow dolly specifications: Max load 4,080 lbs (checked 2026-11-14)
- U-Haul: Tow dolly user instructions: Max speed 55 mph; tow vehicle at least 750 lbs heavier (checked 2026-11-14)
- U-Haul: Auto transport specifications: Max load 5,290 lbs; empty weight 2,210 lbs; max 55 mph (checked 2026-11-14)
- Penske: Tow dolly and car carrier rental: Dolly 4,300 lbs; carrier 4,055–5,000 lbs; Penske truck required (checked 2026-11-14)
- FuelEconomy.gov: Factors that affect fuel economy: Towing a trailer decreases fuel economy (checked 2026-11-14)
- GSA: FY 2026 per diem rates: $110 lodging, $68 meals and incidentals (standard rate) (checked 2026-11-14)